I think the best of the best for pb purists is the 100% organic peanut butter that is ground daily at Natural Grocers (a family owned midwest chain). From their web site:
"Fresh ground peanut butter and almond butter are available everyday. Salt free and sugar free, these nut butters are ground in small batches in every store to ensure you get the freshest product possible. The almonds and organic peanuts used in the products are kept refrigerated in the store coolers until just before grinding. Our fresh ground peanut butter is certified USDA Organic. Enjoy!"
I like that trained store staff do the grinding, so you don't have to worry about your fellow shoppers making a mess of things.