I can't believe no one mentioned the KILLER BROWNIE! Sold at Dorothy Lane Market (one in Oakwood on Main isn't too far from you) it is my favorite thing to get when I go home. Brownie, caramel, chocolate, yum.

Block's bagels is close to Bexley ( 3415 E Broad St) you can definitely get more than an sandwich there. So good, great pastries, and I think most of it is Kosher too.