So, I (again) looked at the places that were suggested. And I could really use some help here. Four restaurants that stand out to me are the following. But, it's impossible to decide which is best without some input. Looking for great food, good value and some ambiance. Thanks!

John's on 12th
Il Vagabondo
Malatesta Trattoria on Washington Street
Rocco's on Thompson St

-----
Malatesta
649 Washington St, New York, NY 10014

We did go to Il Vagabondo a couple of years ago and loved it. The only thing was they rushed us out so quickly. So, we hung around and play bocci ball.

We'd like to know if there is another place with that same kind of vibe. I didn't realize that you could pull my post from 2 years ago. Here were the reccos. Any place you would like to add?

Tanti Baci Cafe http://www.tantibacicaffe.com/tbcnyc....
Frank's Trattoria
Sam's on 39th
Malatesta Trattoria on Washington Street
Rocco's on Thompson St

-----
Malatesta
649 Washington St, New York, NY 10014

Rocco
181 Thompson St, New York, NY 10012

Tanti Baci
41 W 8th St, New York, NY 10011

Frank's Trattoria
371 1st Ave, New York, NY 10010

Sam's Place
132 E 39th St, New York, NY 10016

Looking for an old-school Italian for this Sunday. Which do you like better, Il Vagabondo or JOhn's On 12th? Any other suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

Looking for basic Italian, reasonably priced, with a nice atmosphere. HELP!

We will be spending the day/night in the city on a budget. On our last trip, we had dinner at Il Vagabondo and loved it. After dinner we played bocci ball and had a blast. Looking for another red gravy Italian. Not interested in trendy expensive spots. Just great food in a casual atmosphere. Great people watching would be a bonus! Has anyone heard of Sauce? Any reccos?

We are going to try Il Vagabondo. Thanks so much for the recco!!!

When I say "old fashioned" I mean that I wanted to find a little quaint neighborhoody place, with great inexpensive traditional Italian food like your grandmother used to make. Thanks for the recco. Any other suggestions?

We will be in Manhattan on Sunday, February 14. Would love to eat at a great old-fashioned inexpensive Italian Restaurant. We are staying at 6 Columbus Circle Hotel. BYOB would also be okay. Any recommendations?

I was going to go to Falai for my one night in NY in August. But, since reading this board I am now thinking I should go to Babbo. Is one better than the other?

Also, I wanted to check out the Spotted Pig. Would that be a fun place for lunch? I was also thinking of going to Ssam Bar for lunch.

I would love to hear your opinions. Thanks in advance!

Thank you. I will search for your post on Falai.

Has anyone been to the Spotted Pig?

I have one night in NYC to celebrate my 50th. I prefer small funky restaurants with great food. Love people watching and a fun atmosphere. I was thinking Spotted Pig or Falai.

Maybe I should do Spotted Pig for lunch and Falai for dinner? What do you think?

I also think Belrose is a great option. They have a private room and a semi-private room. In addition, Bistro Cassis has an area in the back of the dining room that is semi-private. A beautiful new BYOB in Berwyn is bistro M. But, no private room. Fleming's is great. But, very expensive. Alba in Malvern is also a wonderful BYOB. But, no private room. Good luck!!

In addition to Meridith's, Kildare's, & Tango are all open for Easter brunch.

Ansill at 3rd and Bainbridge is non smoking.

Rouge is always fun and great people watching! And there's great shopping after lunch.

Here are a few restauranst that I know of on the Main Line, that are serving their regular menus...

333 Belrose in Radnor - upscale creative cuisine

Gypsy Saloon in W. Conshohocken - great Italian and eclectic menu

Nectar in Berwyn - sophisticated and upscale Asian, great atmosphere

Tango in Bryn Mawr - interesting menu with a Latin flavors. Also very nice atmosphere and next to the Bryn Mawr train station.

I have been to George's on several occassions. I've never eaten in the dining room. But, the bar area is really nice. I've had burgers, pizzas, pasta, salads and I have almost always had an enjoyable meal. One time over Christmas my burger took about 45 minutes and was under-cooked. But, other than that, it's been great.

I think it's a fun place to meet for a casual meal!

Coyote Crossing in West Chester has a beautiful new rooftop deck. I was there last Friday night. The food was great and there was a nice looking crowd.