MRG58's Profile

Title Last Reply

Need Best Pizza, Union county

Excellent wood fired Neapolitan pizza, whole pie only, individual and large, $12/$18 range, homemade breads, great sandwiches, salads, local farmer suppliers, BYOB. Same owners as Razza in Jersey City

Arturo's Osteria & Pizzeria
180 Maplewood Ave
Maplewood, NJ

Jun 28, 2015
MRG58 in New Jersey

Anyone try Artisan kitchen bar Hawthorne (Bergen county)?

May 10, 2015
MRG58 in New Jersey

Anyone try Artisan kitchen bar Hawthorne (Bergen county)?


They posted a Mother's Day menu that gives some idea of the type of food they serve. Photos look inviting.

May 10, 2015
MRG58 in New Jersey

Moving to Denville from Montclair....

Try Churrasco Grill in Lake Hiawatha. Its an Argentinian family owned storefront BYOB. Excellent wood grilled meats and fish. Shrimp Isa, crabmeat risotto lamb chops...

May 10, 2013
MRG58 in New Jersey

Pig Roast Central Jersey

Apr 25, 2013
MRG58 in New Jersey

Steakhouse-Northern NJ

River Palm in Edgewater, (NOT Fair Lawn)
Park Steakhouse in Park Ridge

Prime Steakhouse and Beyond, Fort Lee for a storefront BYOB in a converted butcher shop. No atmosphere but excellent, albeit expensive steaks.

For a traditional steakhouse experience, I would go with River Palm. Chopped salad, Porterhouse for two, french fries, crab cakes.

Apr 12, 2013
MRG58 in New Jersey

Good BYOs near Bridgewater, NJ?

I don't believe you will find an excellent BYO within 30 minutes of Bridgewater. A Toute Heurre in Cranford, a bistro setting with outstanding farm to table themed food may be the closest. Blue Bottle Cafe in Hopewell, also a bit further.

Non BYOB that may fit your bill:

Ninety Acres
Peapack Gladstone, NJ

Pluckemin Inn
Bedminster, NJ

Ryland Inn
Whitehouse Station, NJ

Tewksbury Inn
Tewksbury, NJ
You may also find possibilities in New Brunswick.

Apr 12, 2013
MRG58 in New Jersey

Rent a Pig Roasting Box in NJ

I was in the Restaurant Depot in Pine Brook yesterday and noticed they had the La Caja China in their foyer priced at $179.99. Thies may be a regional item and not available at all locations.You need to have a resturanteur or friend that is a member to purchase goods there.

Nov 21, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Hard rolls near Mahwah

Rockland Bakery
94 Demerast Mill Road W
Nanuet, NY

Nov 11, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Fresh Ravioli Monmouth County

This may require a ride North to Maplewood, which I assure you will be worth the effort. This Mom and Pop storefront has the best fresh cheese and meat ravioli, Manicotti and some special varieties. Call ahead to be certain they are available, as they are not made every day and are much better than frozen. You must preorder during Holiday weeks. They also have small pizzas in packages of 6. I'd be curious to learn your opinion.

Depietro Foods
1701 Springfield Avenue
Maplewood, New Jersey

Oct 28, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Staying at Crystal Springs Resort this wknd... Restaurant Recommendations?

I would try Iron Forge Inn in Warwick. Also Belvale Creamery, just up the block. Great ice cream and fantastic view.

Iron Forge Inn
Iron Forge Road
Warwick, New York

Oct 26, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Chinese In Clifton

I would try Chengdu 23 in Wayne
Cheng Du 23
(973) 812-2800 -
57 Rt-23, Wayne, NJ

Oct 19, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Rehearsal Dinner

Have you considered Nicola in Totowa? Excellent Italian BYOB. They have a room that would accommodate your group and are just off Rt 80, not far from West Orange.

Nicola Ristorante
650 Union Blvd
Totowa, NJ

Sep 12, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Rent a Pig Roasting Box in NJ

If you find grilling your own pig too challenging and costly, you may consider The Barbrgue Pit in Bergenfield. Their menu lists whole pig costs of $180 to $195 based on sizes ranging from 28 to 42 lbs. We sampled their small pig at a recent party and found the meat excellent with crisp skin.



Jul 11, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Rent a Pig Roasting Box in NJ

The rental cost is around $100.00 and can hold a larger pig than the China Grill. It has a motor to rotate the pig and is rather heavy. For a smaller pig, it may make more sense to purchase the Caja

A Party Pleasing Rentals
38 W Route 10
East Hanover, NJ

Jul 10, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Rent a Pig Roasting Box in NJ

This link may help you. The grills are relatively inexpensive to buy, but pig roasters are available, given your location.


Jul 09, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Morristown restaurants

For continental, try Blue Morel at the Westin Governor Morris Inn

Jun 24, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Scalini Fedeli -Chatham

Scalini has a $52.00 prix fixe menu, app, mains, sorbet and dessert. Atmosphere is charming, set in an old home. The formal dining room and arched ceilings add an elegant feel. Service has always been top notch. The restaurant has repeatedly received four stars. My favorites include scallop cerciche, Raviolo, Sweet Pea canniloni with lump crab, Swordfish, pounded pork chop, porcini ravioli and the risotto, zabaglone and banana tart. I am certain you will enjoy dining there.

May 14, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Easter Lamb

I would call Ramon, a wholesaler. If he doesn't have a baby lamb available, he may be able to guide you to a butcher that could help.

Hernandez Meat and Provisions
635 Henry St
Elizabeth, New Jersey 07201

Apr 06, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Italian Cheesecake (aka Ricotta Pie)

Lyndhurst Pastry Shop
256 Ridge Road
Lyndhurst, NJ

Apr 04, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

50th Birthday Bergen County HELP!!!

Bergen County restaurants will not generally provide high quality, large portioned, low priced options. For larger eaters, you might try these BYOB Italian restaurants:

I Gemelli
268 Huyler Street
South Hackensack, New Jersey

26 E Prospect Street
Waldwick, New Jersey

Mezzaluna Bistro
97 West Allendale Avenue
Allendale, New Jersey

Mar 18, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

50th Birthday Bergen County HELP!!!

It would be helpful to indicate the size of your group.

I'm not certain El Cid will satisfy your foodies. The others are sound choices.You might also look into Cafe Matisse , a lovely BYOB with a beautiful seasonal garden (depending on group size) in Rutherford or Chakra on Route 4 in Paramus. As to satisfying your wallet, none of these options are inexpensive, but Picnic or Matisse being BYOB may be less costly.

Cafe Matisse
167 Park Avenue
Rutherford, New Jersey

144 Route 4
Paramus, New Jersey

Mar 18, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Hello experts, I need some advice for dinner Saturday night

Jan 28, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Hello experts, I need some advice for dinner Saturday night

Try a family owned storefront with excellent Argentinian food about 40 minutes from Scotch Plains. BYOB, great steaks, fish, "house rice", Crabmeat rissotto,, a special, shrimp eiza, under $50 pp

Churrasco Grill
137 North Beverwyck Rd
Lake Hiawatha, New Jersey

In Bloomfield try byob
Mes Reves
407 Broad Street
Bloomfield, New Jersey

For more formal dinner slightly higher at $66pp. Be certain to look out at their beautiful garden open during mild weather

Cafe Matisse
167 Park Avenue
Rutherford, New Jersey

Jan 28, 2012
MRG58 in New Jersey

Great / artisanal / handmade / mixology cocktails in Maui?

I would suggest:

Merriman's Kapalua
One Bay Club Place
Lahaina, Maui
"Locavore Specialty Cocktails" Locally sourced ingredients, juices are extracted from local fruits, mint basil from their own garden, etc. Our favorite place for dinner/cocktails on Maui. Cliffside oceanfront location with fire ring at oceanfront point, near Kapalua Resort. A must stop. Peter Merrriman is a leader in the Hawaiian Regional Cusine, farm to table concept. We have always enjoyed our meals both there and in Waimea on the Island of Hawaii.

Other dinner suggestions:

Bev Gannon's
Hali'imaile General Store
900 Hali'imaile Road
Makawao, Maui
pinapple upsidown cake a specialty. Visit Makawao town, specialty shops, Komoda's bakery, famous for cream puffs and jelly donuts.

David Paul's Island Grill
900 Front Street
Lahaina, Maui

505 Front Street
Lahaina, Maui
You'll find most of these on Open Table, convenient given the New York time difference.

Kula Lodge
15200 Haleakala Drive
Kula, Maui
Quaint lodge for breakfast,wood fired pizza, spectacular 100 year old garden, views. Make a right our of their lot, go to the end, see farmstand with outrageous strawberries, vegetables and flowers.

89 Hana Highway
Pa'ia, Maui
Pizza for lunch.

Mamma's is not a prioritychoice, imho, where we woud go for the view, not the food. We found the food at Kea Lani to be a disappointment, the cocktails were not memorable.

Have a great trip. I'd love to hear your reviews.

E Komo Mai


Kula Lodge & Restaurant
15200 Haleakala Hwy, Kula, HI 96790

505 Front Street Shops & Restaurants
, Lahaina, HI 96761

Merriman's Kapalua
1 Bay Dr, Lahaina, HI 96761

David Paul's Island Grill
900 Front St Ste A101, Lahaina, HI 96761

Sep 25, 2011
MRG58 in Hawaii

Decent Lunch in South Hackensack?

For Italian, a byob named I Gemelli, the old Aldo and Gianni has always been reliable. Great homemade Pappardelle in Vodka sauce, Stracciatella soup. The seafood specials can be pricey relative to the general menu.

I Gemelli
268 Huyler Street
South Hackensack, NJ

You might also try Clemente for a great Italian hero and prepared dishes.

Clemente Bakery
120 Leuning Street
South Hackensack

Sep 23, 2011
MRG58 in New Jersey

Italian Bread in Newark area.

Calandra's Bakery (also on Rt 46 in Fairfield)
204 First Avenue
Newark, NJ

Nicolo's Italian Bakery
6 Baldwin St
Montclair, NJ

Anthony & Sons Bakery
20 Luger Rd
Denville, NJ

Jul 21, 2011
MRG58 in New Jersey

french and romantic

Sadly, good restaurants in the Route 23 corridor are few and far between. You may consider Rosemary and Sage in Riverdale or LuNello, a formal Italian in Little Falls. For more casual choices we like Churasco , BYO, in Lake Hiawatha for Argentinian grill; Chengdu 23, BYO, Chinese in Wayne; Sonny's in Riverdale for storefront BYO, an Italian sleeper; Yuki Sushi, BYO, in Butler for Japanese and San Giorgio in Kinnelon another casual BYO I talian. All are modest, none would be considered highly rated...

Yuki Sushi
1370 State Rt 23, Butler, NJ 07405

Rosemary and Sage
26 Hamburg Tpke, Riverdale, NJ 07457

Jul 13, 2011
MRG58 in New Jersey

french and romantic

I would suggest Cafe Matisse in Rutherford. Their tasting menu allows you to try many different dishes and includes dessert. Ask Larry to reserve a table for you in their lovely garden and I assure you you will not be disappointed. The setting is intimate with bubbling water features, stone walkways and formal plantings. While the restaurant is BYOB it has a wine shop in front that provides sampling and has an interesting array of choices. The four course "grazing" menu is $65.00, quite reasonable given the high quality of the offerings.

Cafe Matisse
167 Park Ave
Rutherford, New Jersey

Cafe Matisse
167 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070

Jul 13, 2011
MRG58 in New Jersey

Whole Pigs

Forgot to include:

Hernandez Meat and Provisions
635 Henry St
Elizabeth, New Jersey 07201

Jun 23, 2011
MRG58 in New Jersey