racingmoon's Profile
Front Royal - Wynn's or Apple House?
If you're thinking leisurely from NYC to Chincoteague, on one way try stopping in New Castle, DE -- great little historic downtown with old 1700's pubs and restaurants and nice shops and history. Chestertown on the Chesapeake is a great little town -- then come on down via some of the ferries across the Wicomico River. Check out the Ward Museum in Salisbury -- often overlooked but great.
Lots of day trips from Chincoteague that lots of people never do -- Crisfield, Onancock, Wachapreaque, Smith or Tangier Island are worth a stop
Recent Info on Chincoteague
Of your list, the Blackboard Bistro is out of business. Bay WItch has changed hands and I don't know how they are.
Steamed crabs are spicy -- good at Steamers and at Rays Shanty (off island). Saigon Village (Vietnamese) is very good and you can get food as spicy as you want. Bills and the Sea Shell Cafe are your best upscale choices -- the rest are basically seafood. The Isalnd Creamery shouldn't be missed for ice cream