Yes, that's mostly a list of compromises.
Friend of a Farmer certainly looks the part.
I like Good Enough, but not for TDay.
Other ideas include:
Bistro Les Amis
Friend of a Farmer
The Black Duck
Great suggestion but you're right about the price. Zowey limba!
I have a friend coming from Oregon with an allergy to cats so he can't travel in our car or visit our apartment because we have a cat which means we can't go to a favorite New England country inn for Thanksgiving, but (I'm into run-on sentences today) I'd still love to give him a New England Thanksgiving dinner in a New England setting except it has to be in NYC. <whew>