I just want to update my comments... Village Trattoria pizza is starting to get soggy when we order it for take out. Trap Rock has improved - and you can't beat the beer. The Perryville Inn is also fabulous.

I moved here from Melbourne, Australia - a gastronomic feasting ground. Good food is definitely hard to find around here. For 5 star quality (chef used to be sous chef for Jean Georges) is The Pluckemin Inn (in Pluckemin, I believe - close to Bridgewater). It is amazing! The Huntley Tavern (in Summit) has much improved since I moved here in 2004. I personally do not feel that Trap Rock very good. Basilico in Millburn is yummy. In the Short Hills mall: Neiman Marcus cafe for lunch is kind of fun; California Pizza kitchen is good for casual, chain food; Legal Seafood is consistently good. In Summit, Fiorino's for Italian is delicious; Taka Sushi is better than good, Summit Thai is very good (BYO but little atmosphere). I also prefer Village Trattoria for brick oven pizza.