There is a school of thought that contends that the real Old Fashioned must never contain muddled fruit. Hear them out, I think they make a great case:
Robert Hess, on the Old Fashioned:
Rachel Maddow, making the original Old Fashioned:
Shawn Soole, on the original Old Fashioned:
Chris McMillian (a famous bar tender from New Orleans) on the Old Fashioned:
If you watch all of them, you'll see that many of these top bar tenders contend that muddled fruit has no part in this cocktail. I've had it both ways, and I really like it without the muddled fruit.
I tried to submit a recipe, and ran into a lot of frustrations, which I will vent here. If you were to fix these, it would make the system a lot easier to use.
* I would like the ability to save drafts of recipes so I can work on them later.
Please make these changes to the recipe submission form. It would make the form a lot easier to use.
I beg to differ with the presenter of this video. Setting the two parts together at an angle leaves it more likely to leak. Also, when separating the two halves of a Boston style shaker, the glass should be on top, since it is the smaller of the two halves; all the liquid will flow into the larger metal bottom half when they are separated, whereas when the tin is on top, any residual liquid flows down to the lip of the tin rather than into the glass once they're separated.
Also, It is perfectly fine to lock the two together centered on each other. They separate easily if you give the shaker a good tap from the side, as demonstrated in this video explanation of how to use a Boston shaker:
(Starting at 2:58 into the following video)