Thank you for your replys. I am going to make a reservation. I did not know it was cash only. Thanks for the heads up. I will be going to the restaurant for dinner. Is it BYOB as well?

Any additional input would be appreciated. Thank you.

I have never been to Stone Soup and I was having trouble finding any reviews about the restaurant. I know they used to be in Ipswich and I believe they are now in Gloucester. Is it worth making a reservation? What is the menu like?

Thanks for your responses. I will let you know where I go and how it was. Any other suggestions would also be appreciated.

Any suggestions for dinner on V Day anywhere in the boston area? The prix-fixed, over- priced menus are annoying - but I was wondering if anyone had any ideas of places with good food and "reasonable" prices. I know it probably does not exist, but I thought I would ask. Currently thinking of going to Gargoyles at $60/person.

Can't find a menu on their website. How is the food?

Trying to decide between the two places for tonight. Dinner for two. Have never been to either restaurant. Looking for good food and nice atmosphere.

Thank you for all your suggestions - they have been very helpful.

I guess I wasn't specific enough. We have been to pretty much every restaurant you could think of - including probably eating everything on the Chez Henri bar menu. Anything from the White Barn to Ten Tables to Delux. These are three places we have not been. So I wanted to try one. Unless someone can think of somewhere else that has really good moderately priced food knowing that we have eaten at most places. Thanks.

I am taking my girlfriend out for her birthday and we've done all the fancy restaurants - Clio, No. 9, Mistral, etc. I wanted to eat good food without spending all the money. These three restaurants all seemed to fit the bill of moderately priced, good food. Any suggestions would be great. Thanks.