p

ptmph's Profile

Title Last Reply

Traditional Steak House

Thanks everyone for your reviews, however I decided that I want to have the least amount of stress on my birthday, and driving into NYC is stress personified. We decided to go in a different direction and stay in NJ, but have a goregous view of NYC from the window of Le Jardin in Edgewater. We ate there a number of times and never had a bad experience. We're staying with steak, but in a Chateaubriand for two. Thanks again!

Sep 25, 2013
ptmph in Manhattan

Traditional Steak House

We live in Jersey, and in the past for my birthday we used to celebrate at a steakhouse that was reccommended here some years ago: Mignon in Rutherford. Sadly, the restaruant is now gone, and though we tried other steak houses in NJ, my wife wants to treat me to a real traditional steak house in NYC. I've heard of the usual places like Smith & Wollensky, Sparks, Peter Luger, and we'd like to try one of them. Although any other suggestion would be appreciated.

Sep 17, 2013
ptmph in Manhattan

Steakhouse-Northern NJ

I've heard of Wayne Steakhouse and like it being BYOB, like Mignon, plus I live near there.

Apr 12, 2013
ptmph in New Jersey

Steakhouse-Northern NJ

Imagine our disappointment when our favorite steakhouse, Mignon in Rutherford, closed. We're looking for another steakhouse that offers Prime aged beef, a real traditional steakhouse. I've seen advertising for Rare in Little Falls, but I haven't heard anything about it. It's ironic that we first heard about Mignon six years ago here on Chowhound, we trust your recommenations.

Apr 12, 2013
ptmph in New Jersey