I like Stein's and they have bagel flats. The whitefish salad from the Kosher Konner nearby is great

In West Caldwell on Bloomfield Ave near the intersection of Passaic Ave, I think it's called Stein's has good bagels and also bagel flats. Diagonally opposed on Passaic Ave, the Kosher Konner has great whitefish salad.

FD on Rt 22 is Scotch Plains was good the one time I ate there.

FAmous Dave's is good on Rt 22 in Scotch Plains

I also like Pizzatown pizza, calzones that they deep fry and the zepps. If you are in Martha's Vineyard, Giordanos is just like Pizzatown.

I agree with you. The box tastes better than the pizza.