I am new to this, but have loved going through the 79 previous entries. I agree with most of them. My top three are 1587, Ocean Blvd, and Collington Cafe. On the casual front, my wife and I make a regular habit of Tortuga's Lie, and KDG (Kill Devil Grill) is fantastic and still kind of a best kept secret where you don't often have to wait... But while all of these great places were mentioned multiple times, I was suprised more people had not discovered The Pit Surf Shop and Boardriders' Grill. Killer Cali style wraps, hot sammies, burgers and great vegitarian options. Small place, really worth checking out.