Another place that offer ICO oysters are Bin71 on Columbus Ave. They alternate them with Wellfleets. Personally Wellfleets are my favorite for their briny flavor. And to those folks who seem to think I am a plant from the ICO company - wrong...I just grew up there, and I do remember how polluted those waters once were. These oysters are a victory!

As a native of Duxbury, MA I've been keeping my eyes peeled for Island Creeks. You can find them at Cafe Luxembourg on W. 70th Street, and at Per Se in the Time-Warner building.