PEI Lobster Suppers - where to go?

Hey folks,

First off - these boards are great. Thanks to all the regular and not-so-regular contributors - your insight has been very helpful so far in planning the upcoming (unfortunately) few days my wife and I will have in PEI. We arrive this coming saturday and leave tuesday morning.

Secondly, I am looking for a few recommendatons on where to go for a lobster supper. So far I think I have narrowed it to New Glagsow, Cardigans or Water Prince.

Number one priority of course is the food. Location is not a huge issue - but would prefer something on the eastern half of the island. Would love a place that has all you can eat mussels - but this is not a requirement. Friendly (read: unpretentious) service would be a bonus.

Any other suggestions on some good 'home cooking' spots would be much appreciated.

Thanks!

ammo in Atlantic Canada