Even if you only drink Two Buck Chuck, you need a corkscrew. But should you use a basic model that you swiped from a hotel minibar or invest in a fancy boxed-set lever-style corkscrew?
The so-called waiter’s friend is one of the simplest types of corkscrew. It looks like a long, slim pocketknife. Its funny name comes from the fact that it’s found worldwide in waiters’ pockets because it’s a cheap and light wine-opening tool, but you do have to know how to use one.
Screwpull was one of the first to start selling the lever-style corkscrew back in 1979, which some people recognize as rabbit-style. A lot of us have never known a world without it. The lever works against itself, rather than needing a fulcrum, and makes opening wine nearly effortless. Just clamp, close, lift, et voilĂ —it’s wine time. But Screwpulls and their decent imitators are bigger, bulkier, and generally cost more.
The two most respected brands in each style of corkscrew are Pulltap’s and Screwpull. There are a lot of knockoffs out there, so buy from reliable sources. Don’t, uh, get screwed.
If you have a Screwpull that’s not working like it was back in the day, try a replacement screw before you toss it. They do wear out eventually.
For more than you ever wanted to know about corkscrews, check out the Virtual Corkscrew Museum and its newsletter, the Weekly Screw.
Pulltap’s Corkscrew
By Pulltex, $6.95
The finest of the waiter’s friends, it lets you extract a cork in a completely vertical position, so you’re never in danger of breaking the cork. It’s small and light, so you can slip it in your pocket. A serrated blade flips out for cutting the foil. The Teflon-coated worm (the screw) penetrates corks smoothly. Its notched head is also a bottle opener. At publication time, this product was on sale with free shipping from ABestKitchen.com.
QuickSilver Deluxe Lever Style Corkscrew 4 Piece Gift Set
By Wine Enthusiast, $34.95
The sleek chrome finish and stylish ergonomic design of the QuickSilver make it look more expensive than it really is. It’s also heavy—die-cast and zinc-plated—which gives it better leverage. It comes in a gift box that includes a foil cutter, wax remover, and a display base that doubles as a bottle coaster. (The wax remover is kind of superfluous since most waxed wine bottles can simply be opened as if the wax weren’t there, but it’s a thoughtful gesture.) It’s easy to use, well made, and a bargain at the price.
Trigger Wine Opener Set
By Screwpull, $99.95
The newer lever-style Screwpull is even easier to use than the classic. Slip the screw over the bottle neck, and squeeze the trigger to hold everything in place. There’s still the same easy-to-pull lever and Teflon-coated screw. This Williams-Sonoma exclusive boxed set includes a foil cutter, a wine stopper, a drip ring, and an extra screw. It’s worth noting that an extra screw alone costs about $20.
Lever Action Corkscrew (LM400)
By Screwpull, $149.95
This streamlined addition to the Screwpull family is the easiest of all to use: Simply place it over the bottle neck, hold it in place with one hand, then pull the long curved lever up and over to open in one smooth motion. It’s specially designed to open bottles with all kinds of corks and necks, including synthetic corks and flanged necks. Its straightforward style, versatility, comfortable grip, and effortless action make it worth its price. It comes extravagantly packaged in a leather case and includes a foil cutter.
http://www.amazon.com/Screwpull-Classic-Travel-Corkscrew-Black/dp/B000BV5R1A/ref=sr_1_22?ie=UTF8&s=home-garden&qid=1254239118&sr=8-22
Hands down happy with this screwpull travel model. Great for every day use.
Yikes, Bob! While the Ah-So is a terrific cork remover, my advocacy certainly doesn't go so far as to wish you self-mutilation. Go with what works for YOU, I say.
After all, I doubt that a prosthetic hook makes a very practical corkscrew...
Aunt Jenny - be careful. I used a double-bladed cork puller for a while and loved it - until the day I inserted it, grabbed the top of the bottle and gave it a twist to remove the cork, and the top 1/4 inch of the bottle crumbled and ground up the palm of my hand!
I've since gone back to a pulltap-type and have no problems with it. Just a little scar on my right palm to remind me...
Folks, I think it's time we got over Screwpulls, for reasons that will soon be clear. If you believe simplest is best—and it’s hard to argue otherwise—the various Pulltap models are hands-down winners: easy, compact and dirt cheap. (This is not the time for a $200 Laguiole, kids.) Barparts.com began selling Pulltaps several years ago for $7—and still does—even though Restoration Hardware was...+READ
Folks, I think it's time we got over Screwpulls, for reasons that will soon be clear. If you believe simplest is best—and it’s hard to argue otherwise—the various Pulltap models are hands-down winners: easy, compact and dirt cheap. (This is not the time for a $200 Laguiole, kids.) Barparts.com began selling Pulltaps several years ago for $7—and still does—even though Restoration Hardware was charging $30 at the time! If ABestKitchen is still shipping for free, go there. Screwpull has a couple of “travel” models at $30 that are excellent—but after that, I say forget Screwpull. The Metrokane Rabbit lever model (rabbitandriends.com) , $50, is as good or better (has all-metal gearing). A lot of $10 copies from the Far East are around, but they seem to be made in China’s second-tier prisons and fall apart quickly. The best of the lever models streamlined jobs that don’t resemble power tools. Examples: Brookstone’s Connoisseur’s Compact, $40, and the Penguin, $50 at lots of online sellers but only $25!!! at Overstock.com. They operate just like the Screwpull LM 400 shown above (no pliers-type handles clumsily sticking out), except for the fact that the LM 400 is ridiculous. The $150 price is absurd and so is its clumsiness—it weighs about three pounds. Imagine that—a three-pound corkscrew! And do you need a fitted leather case? A mirror-chrome that shows fingerprints?-COLLAPSE
Waiters use those corkscrews because they can open a bottle without having to put it down. You're not supposed to put the bottle on the table until you're finished pouring. I haven't worked in a restaurant in over 15 years and I still feel "wrong" using my Screwpull on the table or even the kitchen counter. Old habits die hard!
I like the lever type corkscrews. Very easy to use. I have a hard time with the pull tap corkscrew, but keep one around for my DD who is a bartender and prefers it. My hands just don't have the same strength hers do, but the lever makes it easy on me.
Jon, there isn't much use weeping over Stelvin-sealed (i.e. screwcap) wine. All that cork has going for it is the romance. Stelvin caps are the best at preventing oxidation of wine, and it's impossible to get a wine that's cork-tainted if there is no cork.
I like pulling the cork out with a "straight-pull" corkscrew (I never knew the name until looking it up a few minutes ago). Looks like this:
http://www.corkscrew.com/pull.html
Definitely not the most efficient tool to use and probably kinda risky, but I love the physical aspect of popping a bottle open. The increased use of screw tops is threatening this pleasure, but to echo Buckethead - from...+READ
I like pulling the cork out with a "straight-pull" corkscrew (I never knew the name until looking it up a few minutes ago). Looks like this:
http://www.corkscrew.com/pull.html
Definitely not the most efficient tool to use and probably kinda risky, but I love the physical aspect of popping a bottle open. The increased use of screw tops is threatening this pleasure, but to echo Buckethead - from what I hear, they are better. I guess that's good news and bad news.
Some trivia from my days in engineering school: natural cork has a Poisson's ratio of nearly zero. This means that when it is pulled lengthwise, its width decreases negligibly. (Most things thin when pulled, right?) I think I remember a textbook saying that cork has the lowest Poisson's ratio of any substance found in nature. Feel free to use this trivia to impress your friends and enemies - I have many times - but you might want to fact-check my memory first.-COLLAPSE
Screw tops ain't what they used to be, the new types work better than natural cork.
Thanks for the acknowledgment, Jon...
Tho' I have to tell you that I carry my Ah-So in my handbag at all times (excluding airplanes since 9/11... though Security never much liked the device even before that), knowing that I have a Ninja weapon in case I'm approached on the street by someone brandishing a bad attitude... OR a nice Bordeaux...
I've a number of corkscrews--stand-mounted and hand-held--and one of the cork extractors Aunt Jenny mentioned, and the last individual I invited over for dinner brought with her a screw-top bottle of wine.
It made me want to weep.
All that aside, I love the waiter's friend style: it's convenient having something close to hand when going to a friend's house for a wine tasting, especially if...+READ
I've a number of corkscrews--stand-mounted and hand-held--and one of the cork extractors Aunt Jenny mentioned, and the last individual I invited over for dinner brought with her a screw-top bottle of wine.
It made me want to weep.
All that aside, I love the waiter's friend style: it's convenient having something close to hand when going to a friend's house for a wine tasting, especially if they can't find their own.-COLLAPSE
I still favor the Ah-So:
http://www.corkscrew.com/sales_monopol_ahso.html
I know most people hate it (ending up driving the cork into the bottle, etc.), but if you rock it in and twist it out, even the driest, crumbliest, most stubborn corks come out whole... and you've made no hole in the cork!
I think one we have at home is the Wine Enthusiast QuickSilver, or something very close to it. I love how effortlessly it opens bottles, but only wish it weren't so bulky.
I found one of those Trigger things at Community Thrift for three bucks, and it rules...but after a good six months or so of regular use, it's starting to go all wonky.
I Love the pulltap Parrot...
Of all the different corkscrews I've used, I have found that simplest is the best. There's a reason you don't see the screwpull type corkscrews in bars. I got mine from IKEA and love it (very nice lines whether open or closed; my one quibble is that the worm is a tad thick) but the one featured in this article looks like a very decent one.