The 10 Best Margherita Pizzas in the Bay Area

Legend has it that Italy's Queen Margherita so admired the red, white, and green of her nation’s flag that pizzaiolos in Naples named their tomato, mozzarella, and basil-leaf pizzas after her. A properly made pizza margherita is one of Italy's proudest achievements, and the San Francisco Bay Area is one of three or four places in the world where it achieves a state of perfection. Here, in alphabetical order, are 10 margheritas Bay Area Chowhounds like to show off to their out-of-town friends.

1. CAFFE BAONECCI
516 Green Street, San Francisco
415-989-1806

Roman-style pizza in an unpretentious setting. The pies are small, so plan to order one per person—at least.

2. DEL POPOLO
Mobile, check Twitter for location details
415-967-1853
Order a margherita cooked in an Italian-made wood-fired oven behind the glass wall of the Del Popolo truck, then dig into a basil-heavy pie with a chewy crust (pictured).

3. DOPO
4293 Piedmont Avenue, Oakland
510-652-3676

Small pie, big flavor: Mozzarella di bufala makes this margherita special.

4. FLOUR + WATER
2401 Harrison Street, San Francisco
415-826-7000

Arrive either very early or very late to this Mission District restaurant, where half the tables are reserved for walk-ins and a multiple-hour wait is a given (even for the late Steve Jobs). Follow that margherita with chocolate budino.

5. FORGE
66 Franklin Street, Oakland
510-268-3200

The wood-fired crust at this new spot in Oakland’s Jack London Square has already impressed with its perfect balance of chewy and crispy. Place your order, then chill in the outdoor dining area warmed by fire pits.

6. PAZZIA
337 Third Street, San Francisco
415-512-1693

A dark horse you won’t see lighting up Foursquare or a glossy magazine's best-of list, but Chowhounds say there's just something about the margherita here. Good news for tourists: It's walkable from both Union Square and SFMOMA.

7. PIZZAIOLO
5008 Telegraph Avenue, Oakland
510-652-4888

Crushed tomatoes lend a gently sweet flavor to the wood-fired beauties at this restaurant in Oakland’s Temescal neighborhood. Order a gin and tonic (the latter's house-made) as a treat before dinner. The identical margherita emerges from the oven at Pizzaiolo's Grand Lake spin-off, Boot and Shoe Service (3308 Grand Avenue, Oakland, 510-763-2668).

8. PIZZERIA DELFINA
Mission District location
3611 18th Street, San Francisco
415-537-6800

Pacific Heights location
2406 California Street, San Francisco
415-440-1189

Intense tomato flavor and a chewy crust recommend the margherita at this pizzeria with two locations. Pacific Heights has better seating (especially for large groups) and an extended menu, but 'hounds give the Mission original the edge for consistency.

9. TONY’S PIZZA NAPOLETANA
1570 Stockton Street, San Francisco
415-835-9888

With its airy, charred crust, this deeply satisfying pizza is among the very best in the city, according to devoted pizza eater joe_can_bike, and it won the World Pizza Cup in Naples. Tony's makes only 73 STG (an Italian initialism for “guaranteed typical specialty”) margheritas per day.

10. UNA PIZZA NAPOLETANA
210 11th Street, San Francisco
415-861-3444

A cult favorite from pizza chef Anthony Mangieri, who moved his operation from New York to San Francisco in 2010, this place gets high marks for its zenlike simplicity: few choices, no substitutions, just a classic Neapolitan margherita made with buffalo mozzarella and obsessiveness.

Photo of Del Popolo pizza by Chris Rochelle / CHOW.com


View San Francisco Margherita Pizza: Chowhound Lists in a larger map