Grey Lady styles itself as a Nantucket fish shanty—"the seafood shack by way of Ralph Lauren," the Times called it—but recent Chowhound talk suggests there's substance there, too. Confessed "lobster roll fanatic" Motosport singles out a generously filled, subtly dressed version (pictured) that measures up well against the best he's had, from the Hamptons to Maine. His party also sampled oysters on the half shell, a tasty lobster pot pie with sherry-cream sauce, and a shepherd's pie, and "everyone was impressed."
Grey Lady [Lower East Side]
77 Delancey Street (between Allen and Orchard streets), Manhattan
Photo by Grey Lady / Facebook